Item 7 is management's discussion and analysis. People say MD&A.
Item 7 is management's discussion and analysis. People say MD&A.
It is the year explained by the people who ran it. The statements tell you what happened. MD&A tells you why the company says it happened, and it is the only place in the filing where that explanation is required.
It is built around changes. Almost every sentence compares this year with last year. Sales rose or fell by this much because of that. Costs moved for this reason. If you want the story of a year in ten paragraphs, this is where it lives.
Apple's MD&A for the year that ended September 30 2023, against the year before.
| Line | FY2023 ($M) | FY2022 ($M) |
|---|---|---|
| Products net sales | 298,085 | 316,199 |
| Services net sales | 85,200 | 78,129 |
| Total net sales | 383,285 | 394,328 |
Apple's own words for two of those lines. Total net sales decreased 3% or $11.0 billion. Services net sales increased 9%.
The products line moved too. $298,085 million against $316,199 million is a fall of $18,114 million, or about 6%. Note what just happened. The 3% and the 9% are quoted from the document. The 6% is derived, by you, from two figures the document states. Both are honest. Only one is a quotation.
Now put the three together and you have the year. Products fell by about $18 billion. Services rose by about $7 billion. Services absorbed roughly 40% of the products decline, which is why the total only fell 3% while its largest component fell 6%.
That is what MD&A is for. Not the numbers. The shape of them.
The trap is reading MD&A as neutral.
Management writes it. Management chooses which comparisons to feature, which percentages to state in words, and which movements appear only as a column in a table. Apple states the services increase in a sentence. The products decline is left to the table. Neither choice is improper. Both are choices.
So read MD&A for the explanation and check the explanation against Item 8. When a percentage appears in the text, note it as quoted. When you work one out yourself, note it as derived and show the arithmetic. Writing down which is which takes two seconds and it is the difference between a figure someone can check and a figure someone has to trust.
Your manager saw a headline saying Apple had a down year and wants to know how bad it was.
What did total net sales do and where is that stated?
They decreased 3%, or $11.0 billion, to $383,285 million. Apple states that in Item 7.
What did services do?
Services net sales increased 9% to $85,200 million. Also stated in Item 7.
Work out what products did and label it.
$316,199 million to $298,085 million. A fall of $18,114 million, about 6%. Derived from the two stated figures.
Give your manager one sentence.
Products fell about $18 billion and services grew about $7 billion, so the total fell only 3%. The down year was a products year.
Ten minutes. Free. Nothing to install.
Take this class