What a stock grant actually is

Day 01 of 12Intro to Equity CompensationTen minutes

Equity compensation is pay delivered in shares instead of cash.

Teach 1

The definition

Equity compensation is pay delivered in shares instead of cash.

The common form is a restricted stock unit. An RSU is a promise. The company agrees to give you a number of shares at a future date if you are still there. Until that date you hold nothing you can sell. You hold a claim that turns into shares later.

Three words do most of the work in this course.

Grant. The day the company makes the promise and the number of units is fixed.

Vest. The day a portion of that promise turns into shares you own.

Settle. The moment the shares actually land in your account, usually the same day as vesting.

The number of units is set at grant. What those units are worth is set by the share price whenever they vest. Those are two different things and confusing them is the most expensive mistake in this subject.

Teach 2

The worked example

Equity compensation is not a fringe cost. It shows up as an expense in the accounts like wages do.

Apple, fiscal year ended September 30 2023Value ($M)
Share-based compensation expense10,833
Total net sales383,285

$10,833 million divided by $383,285 million is 0.028. About 2.8% of everything Apple sold went out as share-based compensation.

Think about what that expense represents. It is not cash leaving the business. Apple did not write $10,833 million of cheques. It handed over shares, and accounting rules require the company to charge the value of those shares against profit as employees earn them.

So the cost is real for shareholders and the cash is not spent. That combination is the whole reason companies use equity. It pays people, it conserves cash, and it hands the bill to existing owners in the form of more shares outstanding. Day 7 is about what that does to them.

Teach 3

The trap

The trap is treating a grant as money you have.

An offer letter that says $200,000 of RSUs is describing a number of units, calculated from a share price on a date near the grant. The units are fixed. The value is not. If the share price halves before anything vests, that line in your offer letter is worth $100,000. If it doubles it's worth $400,000. Nothing about the promise changed.

The second trap is the opposite mistake. People hear that equity is uncertain and treat it as worthless. It isn't. In FY2023 Apple charged $10,833 million of it against profit, and every dollar of that reached an employee as shares. It is real pay with a variable amount.

Hold both ideas at once. The grant is a real thing. Its value is not known until it vests.

Put it on a real company

A friend has an offer with $120,000 of RSUs over four years and asks whether that's really $30,000 a year.

  1. Step 1

    What is actually fixed in that offer?

    The number of units, calculated from a share price around the grant date. Not the dollar value.

  2. Step 2

    What decides what she receives each year?

    The share price on each vesting date, multiplied by the units vesting that day.

  3. Step 3

    She asks whether the company can simply pay less if the price falls.

    No. The promise is units. A price fall makes them worth less. It does not reduce the count.

  4. Step 4

    Give her one sentence to hold on to.

    You are being granted a fixed number of units and a variable amount of money, and the only date that fixes the money is the day each piece vests.

Check yourself

  1. What is a restricted stock unit?
  2. Apple's share-based compensation expense was $10,833 million on total net sales of $383,285 million. What share of sales was it?
  3. Your offer says $200,000 of RSUs. The share price halves before anything vests. What happened?
Answer these in the app

Where these figures come from

Every figure on the site, with its document

What this class introduces

This is the first classIntro to Equity Compensation
The class afterHow vesting works

A grant fixes the number of units. The share price on the vesting day fixes the money.

Ten minutes. Free. Nothing to install.

Take this class